Why America Needs More Coercion Not Less

Why America Needs More Coercion Not Less

The foreign policy establishment suffers from a collective delusion. For decades, the dominant choir has sung the same tired hymn about American coercion. The narrative runs on rails: Washington swings a heavy stick, sovereign states fracture under the pressure, regional stability evaporates, and peace retreats into the fog of war. Pundits demand multilateral harmony, gentle diplomacy, and the quiet withdrawal of American leverage from international markets and security architectures.

They call it pragmatism. I call it professional malpractice.

Why America Needs More Coercion Not Less

news

Foreign policy pundits love a clean narrative. They sit in temperature-controlled think tanks in Washington, sip artisan coffee, and type out manifestos lamenting the heavy hand of American power. The lazy consensus says coercion fails, dialogue cures everything, and the global order survives on mutual respect rather than raw leverage.

It sounds wonderful. It also ignores how the physical world actually works.

I have spent years watching international negotiations stall while diplomats draft polite statements that nobody reads. I have seen adversaries pocket concessions, smile for the cameras, and accelerate their military buildups the moment the threat of economic strangulation or military retaliation was removed from the table. The naive belief that nations abandon ambition because we ask nicely is a dangerous fairy tale.

America's foreign policy of coercion is not failing because coercion is wrong. It is failing because we stopped doing it properly. We applied half-measures, signaled our own fatigue, and expected compliance without consequence.

The Myth of Permanent Diplomacy

The standard critique argues that sanctions destroy economies, alienate populations, and drive rivals into each other's arms. Critics point to blocked trade routes or frozen assets and cry humanitarian disaster.

They miss the point entirely.

Coercion is not designed to win popularity contests. It is an instrument of statecraft meant to alter the calculation of hostile actors when standard diplomacy hits a wall. When Thomas Schelling wrote The Strategy of Conflict, he did not describe a universe governed by peaceful consensus. He mapped a world where credible threats dictate outcomes. If you remove the credible threat, you remove deterrence.

Look at what happens when Washington blinks. When red lines become suggestions, revisionist powers do not dial back their territorial ambitions. They expand them. History offers a brutal reminder: power abhors a vacuum, and restraint by a superpower is universally interpreted as weakness by its rivals.

Imagine a scenario where the United States completely abandons economic pressure, tariffs, secondary sanctions, and forward-deployed naval deterrence in favor of pure multilateral dialogue. Within twenty-four months, shipping lanes in the South China Sea close, regional partners cut bilateral deals with local hegemons out of sheer survival instinct, and the dollar loses its reserve status because global stability vanished. Coercion is the ugly tax we pay to keep global trade moving.

What Real Leverage Looks Like

To make coercion work, you need three things that modern policymakers routinely throw away: asymmetry, consistency, and absolute ruthlessness regarding your own national interests.

First, asymmetry means accepting that equal partnerships are rare. If you treat a rival like an equal while trying to coerce them, you project confusion. Economic coercion works when the cost of non-compliance to the target dwarfs the cost of compliance. When we issue weak waivers or grant endless exemptions to favored corporate lobbies, we neuter the weapon.

Second, consistency means sticking to the timeline. Dictators and autocrats watch American election cycles like hawks. They know our political system has the attention span of a goldfish. If a target believes they only need to wait out an administration for sanctions to soften, coercion turns into a mild annoyance rather than a structural constraint.

Third, we must stop pretending our foreign policy goals are entirely altruistic. Pretending that every punitive measure is launched solely to protect human rights invites charges of hypocrisy, which weakens moral authority. Let us be honest: coercion protects structural stability, security architectures, and economic lifelines.

The Cost of Retreat

The alternative to hard-nosed leverage is not peace. It is chaos managed by whoever is willing to be the most ruthless.

When critics demand an end to coercive diplomacy, they are asking the United States to abdicate its role as the global anchor and hand the reins to states that do not share our baseline tolerance for free expression, open markets, or basic sovereignty. If you dislike the current global order governed by American economic and military weight, try living in one managed entirely by unchecked regional autocrats.

We do not need less coercion. We need strategic coherence. We need leaders who understand that power is a use-it-or-lose-it asset. Stop apologizing for having the biggest stick in the room and start swinging it with precision.

MJ

Miguel Johnson

Drawing on years of industry experience, Miguel Johnson provides thoughtful commentary and well-sourced reporting on the issues that shape our world.