Why Los Angeles Can Build Apartments Without Wrecking Measure ULA

Why Los Angeles Can Build Apartments Without Wrecking Measure ULA

Los Angeles has a bad habit of treating housing policy like a zero-sum death match. You either want to protect funding for affordable housing, or you want developers to build massive apartment complexes without bureaucratic friction. Pick a side.

Except that framing is completely false.

The ongoing war over Measure ULA—the city's transfer tax on high-value property sales meant to fund homelessness prevention and affordable housing—misses a larger truth. You don't have to gut a voter-approved revenue source just to get cranes back in the sky. But right now, developers, neighborhood activists, and city hall are locked in a circular firing squad while the housing shortage keeps getting worse.

The Real Cost of the Transfer Tax Standoff

When voters passed Measure ULA, the pitch was simple: tax property sales over five million dollars to fund the creation of low-income units. It sounded like a straightforward way to make wealthy real estate transactions pay for the city's deepest crisis.

Real-world economics are rarely that tidy. Data from groups like the RAND Corporation and local real estate analysts show that high transfer taxes can choke transaction volumes, freezing the very market property taxes rely on. Large-scale multi-family developments have slowed down significantly, caught between high interest rates, construction costs, and the heavy bite of the ULA tax on commercial and large residential sales.

Critics argue the tax is killing new apartment construction before it starts. Developers pull back, capital heads to friendlier submarkets, and overall housing supply stagnates.

At the same time, affordable housing advocates point out an obvious reality: slashing Measure ULA strips away hundreds of millions of dollars earmarked for people who have nowhere else to go. Giving up that revenue stream means abandoning thousands of households to the streets.

So both sides dig in. The developers blame the tax for ruining the math on new builds. The advocates blame developers for prioritizing profit margins over human lives. Meanwhile, the city keeps sinking deeper into affordability hell.

How to Fix the Math Without Slashing the Safety Net

The mistake is assuming that tweaking or preserving Measure ULA is the only lever Los Angeles can pull. The city has plenty of other ways to encourage apartment development without touching a single penny of the mansion tax.

Start with zoning reform and parking minimums. For decades, municipal code mandated absurd amounts of unused parking space for new apartment buildings, adding hundreds of thousands of dollars to construction costs per project. When you force builders to construct underground parking structures they don't need, you kill moderately priced apartments before the first shovel hits the dirt.

Streamlining the approval process matters just as much. If a mid-sized apartment project takes eighteen months of environmental reviews and neighborhood hearings just to get a stamp, holding costs will eat up the budget. Cutting red tape doesn't cost the city tax revenue. It just requires political will at City Hall to tell endless obstructionist committees to stand down.

Why Compromise Keeps Failing in L.A. Politics

The reason Los Angeles stays stuck is ideological purity.

Progressive groups view any compromise on Measure ULA as a betrayal of working-class renters and unhoused residents. Real estate interests view any tax above a baseline minimum as an existential threat to private enterprise.

Neither stance survives contact with basic arithmetic. Rents won't drop until total housing supply climbs significantly. But supply won't help tomorrow morning's emergency if vulnerable families are displaced today.

Los Angeles needs both private-market construction to ease long-term pricing pressure and publicly funded safety nets for immediate relief. Pretending these two goals are mutually exclusive is a luxury a city with this level of housing distress can't afford.

Instead of waging endless proxy wars over whether to repeal or defend a single ballot measure, local leaders need to focus on what actually moves the needle. Fast-track permits for multi-family infill, fix the outdated municipal codes that penalize density, and let developers build without treating every apartment complex like an assault on the neighborhood character.

You can fund affordable housing and still build the apartments L.A. desperately needs. It just requires dropping the ideological baggage at the city limits.

MJ

Miguel Johnson

Drawing on years of industry experience, Miguel Johnson provides thoughtful commentary and well-sourced reporting on the issues that shape our world.