Every few months, the Israeli political press prints the exact same headline. The opposition accuses Benjamin Netanyahu of trying to delegitimize an upcoming or recent election, and international observers nod along as if they just uncovered a novel authoritarian plot.
They are wrong. Worse, they are boring.
By treating Netanyahu’s rhetoric around electoral integrity, judicial oversight, and coalition legitimacy as a sudden, unprecedented assault on democratic norms, opposition leaders are falling into a trap they helped build. They are fighting a public relations war over process while ignoring the structural realities of Israeli parliamentary math. If you want to understand why Israel’s political system is perpetually on the brink, stop listening to the outrage cycles in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem and start looking at how both sides weaponize institutional distrust.
The Lazy Consensus on "Delegitimization"
The standard media narrative goes like this: Benjamin Netanyahu, facing political survival pressures and ongoing legal battles, attacks the Central Elections Committee, the Supreme Court, or the legitimacy of votes cast by Arab-Israeli citizens. The opposition—led by figures like Yair Lapid, Benny Gantz, or Yair Golan—immediately sounds the alarm. They warn that questioning the mechanics of the vote destroys public trust and mirrors right-wing populist tactics seen in the United States or Hungary.
That analysis is surface-level nonsense.
It assumes that Israeli voters view their electoral institutions as neutral, sacred ground that is only now being polluted by Likud talking points. Anyone who has spent five minutes inside an Israeli campaign war room knows that institutional skepticism is the baseline operating system of the entire country.
In a proportional representation system with a 3.25% electoral threshold, nobody wins an outright mandate. Every government is a fragile, transactional marriage of convenience cobbled together after the ballots are counted. Because voters never actually choose their government directly—they only choose the size of the negotiating blocs—every single faction treats the post-election horse-trading as inherently suspect when they lose.
When the opposition screams that Netanyahu is "delegitimizing" the vote, they are pretending that electoral legitimacy in Israel is a fragile porcelain vase. In reality, it is a battering ram that every major political bloc has swung at its rivals for decades.
How Both Blocs Weaponize Institutional Doubt
Let’s look at the actual history instead of the selective amnesia practiced by party spokespeople.
During the five-election deadlock between 2019 and 2022, the anti-Netanyahu bloc routinely framed any coalition containing Netanyahu—even if he won the most votes and secured a 61-seat Knesset majority—as morally and democratically illegitimate due to his criminal indictments. Think about what that communicates to a Likud voter in Beersheba or Ashdod. You cast a legal ballot. Your candidate wins a majority of seats in the parliament. And the opposition tells you that your vote shouldn't count because the Supreme Court and the Attorney General’s office have tainted the winner.
Now flip the coin. When Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid formed the "change government" in 2021, they relied on Ra'am, an independent Islamist party, to reach 61 seats. Netanyahu and his allies immediately branded the government a fraudulent theft of right-wing votes, arguing that Bennett had betrayed his campaign promises and that relying on non-Zionist parties violated the spirit of Israeli democracy.
Both arguments rely on the exact same mechanism: defining legitimacy not by the literal rules of the Knesset, but by your own tribe's ideological red lines.
Political scientists like Giovanni Sartori and Arend Lijphart spent careers studying deeply divided societies with proportional systems. In fractured democracies, procedural rules are supposed to be the one thing everyone agrees on when they hate each other's policies. In Israel, the rules themselves are the primary battlefield. There is no written constitution. Basic Laws can be amended with a bare majority. The boundary between the Supreme Court’s judicial review and the Knesset’s legislative supremacy has been contested since the 1990s constitutional revolution led by Aharon Barak.
When the opposition accuses Netanyahu of breaking the system, they are projecting an illusion of stability that never existed.
What Critics Get Wrong About Netanyahu's Strategy
If you look closely at Netanyahu’s rhetoric surrounding elections, voter fraud, or ballot monitoring, he rarely needs to overturn a certified result to win. That is an American framework applied clumsily to a Middle Eastern parliament.
In a winner-take-all presidential system, challenging an election means trying to flip state certifications after the fact. In Israel’s parliamentary system, challenging electoral legitimacy serves three completely different tactical purposes:
- Base Mobilization Through Grievance: Likud’s core electoral problem is rarely persuasion; it is turnout. Right-wing voters in peripheral cities often stay home when they feel comfortable. Convincing them that the "elites," the media, and the Central Elections Committee are actively trying to steal their voice is the single most effective turnout machine in Israeli politics.
- Pre-empting Coalition Defections: In a 120-seat Knesset, a majority of 61 means a single backbencher holds veto power over the entire government. By framing the political arena as an existential war between the "legitimate national camp" and an "illegitimate deep-state coalition," Netanyahu raises the social and political cost for any right-wing politician considering defecting to the center.
- Shifting the Overton Window on Judicial Oversight: Every time the opposition defends the Central Elections Committee (which is chaired by a Supreme Court justice), they accidentally reinforce Netanyahu’s broader argument: that unelected judges hold final authority over the will of the voters.
The opposition falls for this every single time. By rushing to microphones to defend the sanctity of the institutions, Lapid and Gantz willingly cast themselves as the defenders of the status quo establishment, while handing Netanyahu the populist mantle of the outsider fighting for the common voter.
The Questions Nobody Is Asking
When international outlets cover these clashes, readers usually ask two predictable questions: Is Israeli democracy actually collapsing? and Could Netanyahu refuse to leave office if he loses?
Both questions miss the mark because they focus on dramatic, cinematic coups rather than slow institutional erosion.
First, Israeli democracy is not collapsing; it is ossifying into permanent tribal gridlock. Elections in Israel are extraordinarily secure from a technical standpoint. Paper ballots, transparent counting, party observers at every polling station, and rapid tabulation make actual vote-rigging virtually impossible on a scale that could alter Knesset seat distribution. Even the infamous camera-in-polling-stations controversy pushed by Likud operatives in Arab towns years ago was never about altering ballot counts—it was about voter suppression and generating viral campaign footage.
Second, Netanyahu has already left office peacefully once before, in June 2021, when the Knesset voted in the Bennett-Lapid government. He didn't barricade himself in Balfour Street. He walked across the aisle to the opposition benches, spent eighteen months dismantling the fragile eight-party coalition from the floor of the parliament, and returned to power through the ballot box in November 2022.
He doesn't need to break the constitutional transfer of power when the parliamentary math already does the heavy lifting for him.
Where the Opposition’s Strategy Fails
I’ve watched political consultants across multiple democracies burn through tens of millions of dollars running "defender of democracy" campaigns against populist incumbents. It almost never works as a standalone message.
Voters who already care deeply about institutional norms are already voting for the opposition. Screaming about delegitimization doesn't win over a single undecided voter in Petah Tikva who is worried about the cost of groceries, housing prices, or reserve duty fatigue. To an undecided voter, two politicians arguing over who respects democratic norms more sounds like two lawyers arguing over billing hours while the house is on fire.
Worse, the opposition’s obsession with Netanyahu’s rhetoric masks their own failure to offer a coherent governing alternative.
Look at the numbers. Between 2019 and 2022, the anti-Netanyahu bloc proved they could unite around a single negative premise: Anyone But Bibi. What they could not do was govern once they got the keys. A coalition stretching from the far-left Meretz to the right-wing Yamina and the Islamist Ra'am collapsed within a year because they agreed on nothing except their hatred of one man.
Until the opposition stops treating Netanyahu as a comic-book villain subverting an otherwise pristine system, they will keep losing the narrative war.
The Real Threat Nobody Wants to Admit
To be clear, admitting that the opposition’s framing is flawed does not mean Netanyahu’s tactics are harmless. There is a massive downside to normalizing suspicion of election administrators and judges, even when done for short-term tactical gain.
Once you train millions of citizens to believe that any electoral outcome they dislike is the product of institutional sabotage, you cannot simply turn that switch off when you return to power. Trust in public institutions takes decades to build and months to liquidate. When the next genuine national crisis hits—whether a security failure, an economic shock, or a constitutional clash between the Knesset and the High Court—the public has no shared referee left to call balls and strikes.
That is the real danger. Not a stolen election, and not a refusal to vacate the Prime Minister’s residence. It is the total evaporation of a shared reality between rival blocs of citizens who still have to live in the same tiny country, serve in the same military, and pay into the same economy.
If Israel’s opposition actually wants to counter Netanyahu, they need to abandon the pearl-clutching press conferences about "delegitimization." Stop lecturing voters on democratic etiquette. Force the conversation back onto tangible governance, economic relief, security accountability, and passing a formal Basic Law on Legislation that finally defines where the Knesset ends and the Supreme Court begins.
Until they do that, every outrage cycle they manufacture just hands Netanyahu another megaphone—and another four years to use it.